I should have known it it all along. Most likely, Pam did. We went to see Shania Twain at Staples last night, and, frankly, I did not know what to expect. We had never seen her perform live before. Sure, we knew, and loved, her vintage music. We are not alone, as she probably is the biggest selling female country music artist of all time, though I suspect Taylor Swift would eclipse her if she stayed country. But all of that is moot. Recently, Shania has had personal tragedies that have kept her out of the limelight and possibly affected the quality of her voice.
These events definitely affected her music. In the 90s she was the queen of pop country, turning out one extremely pleasant song after another. Songs that were fun to listen to with light lyrics and catchy tunes. Songs that were so good that they even inspired guys to sing about feeling like a woman.
Recently, she released Now, her first album in years. We received a copy of it several months ago, as it came with the tickets to her show. The first time each of us listened to Now we were unimpressed. Gone was the sweet, high pitched voice. Gone were the catchy tunes and simplistic lyrics. Gone was the country, though there was never a ton of country in her anyway. Gone was the pop. In its place was a cathartic expression of life accompanied by a deeper, more mature voice.
After listening to Now several times in preparation for the show, we realized that Now also had substance. It grew on us, as we kept listening to it. We just weren’t sure how it would translate to a live show, and how it would coexist with her earlier works. We also were concerned that her new, lower voice would not work when she sang her older material. It turned out we had nothing to worry about.
Her show was spectacular, in all senses of the word. Maybe, just maybe, the 100+ shows she did in Las Vegas several years ago had something to do with that, as this was a production with a capital P. Every aspect of it was superb. From the staging to the sound and the visuals, from the backup singers to the dancers and the band, everything was perfect. The mix was remarkable, enabling all vocals and instruments to be heard clearly and distinctly, not something we usually experience. Her entrance was fitting of Rocky Balboa or Apollo Creed. It was a focused assault on our senses, fueled by drummer Elijah Wood’s rhythmic, spiritual beating on drums located at the back of the arena, providing all the pulse pounding accompaniment Shania needed for her long walk through the audience before getting to the stage.
As she sang the opening bars of her first song, Life’s About to Get Good, we had a feeling we were in for a treat. And by the time she got through Come on Over and Up!, a couple of songs later, we knew it. So did everyone else in Staples.
Pam loves productions like this. For her, last night was a party, an exuberant expression of art and music. I am usually a bit less enthusiastic about productions like this. Generally, I like stripped down, acoustic performances. Generally, I like the absence of costume changes. Generally, I avoid shows with dancers, as they usually take away from the music. Not last night. Shania’s show featured everything I profess to disdain, including umpteen costume changes. I liked, no loved, it, despite, and maybe because of, its production quality and the showmanship she possesses. And, yes, she can still sing.
Brandy Clark, on the other hand, is one of my favorite singers. Generally, performers need a shtick. Most great ones have a charm, a charismatic style, a ton of energy that pulls the crowd along with them. There are several notable exceptions to this, including Eric Clapton and Chris Stapleton, who can almost stand motionless while they play without losing their audience. Their music is that good. Brandy Clark is a singer, not an entertainer. Though she sings about crimes of fashion, we generally see her perform in basic black. She is almost as motionless as Stapleton and as expressionless as Clapton when she plays, though she does have a nice rapport with the audience when she chooses to use it. In my opinion, she is totally captivating without moving around on stage, and I could spend hours listening to her perform.
Zac performs so well live, and he is a joy to listen to. He wowed us with his guitar playing, as he and the band really cranked up the tempo on a couple of numbers. We felt so good after the show we were singing Zac songs and yacking about the concert all the way back to our car, which was parked 20 minutes away from the Bowl. The next day we flew to Wailea for some much needed vacay. That night we sat on our balcony, drinking Mai Tais as we enjoyed our ocean view and watched our first sunset of the week. As we did so, we were still feeling good about the show. So good that Pam played a steady stream of Zac YouTube concert videos on her iPad. These is no doubt that we will see him a fourth time.
and Kris left after three songs. Pam wanted to go with them. I was more into it, so I made her stay two more songs. Then she and I left. The Old 97s have been together since 1993, and their music is best described as alt-country, which encompasses roots rock, bluegrass, rockabilly, honky-tonk, outlaw country, folk, and punk rock. The night we saw them it seemed like they had forsaken every genre but punk, pure, loud punk. Screaming loud punk. Jumping around the stage punk. Any notes that were sung on key were purely accidental, or so that is how we felt. John, Kris and Pam have given me a much deserved ration of shit about them ever since.
The opening act, Kate Micucci, was okay. She was more of a comic than a singer. She has written a slew of funny songs with quirky lyrics. She sung them in a sweet, little girl like voice. And, for a while, they were fun. She also had a few of her friends assisting her with some pure comedy shtick. In total she had about 20 minutes of funny songs and comedy bits. It was unfortunate that she crammed those 20 minutes into a 45 minute set, resulting in me wanting her to leave the stage well before she actually did.
time.”. Despite the obviousness of this quote, people continue to test the veracity of it, and they continue to find out just how true it is, even applied to small, reasonably homogenous groups, like concert goers.
The show itself was fun. The opening act, Rachel Platten, was really a bit out there for a country show. She performed like a teeny bopper, despite the fact that she is in her mid 30s. Her songs were a mix of pop and indie pop genres, and I am not a fan of either. Unfortunately for me, she truly loves her bass. I, however, do not. I usually gripe about the bass rattling through my torso and up into my head. For some reason, it lodged in my right shin at the show. That did not make it any better, and I swear I had a shin splint in my right leg the next day. Having said that, she is a good entertainer with an excellent voice. She put on a good show and finished it with Fight Song, which is a great underdog anthem and is near and dear to Pam. Pretty soon it was Tim and Faith time. They came out together. Sang songs together. Sang songs separately. Sang songs together. Left the stage together, we think, because we snuck out just as the encore started. Each song was good, but something was amiss. Something was a little off. Maybe it was crowd energy. Maybe it was chemistry on stage. Maybe it was genre conflict.
delivered perfectly. Tim sort of nailed it, sometimes sounding really pinched as he drawled out some of his less gritty material. At times he was amazing, especially when he sang Live Like You Were Dying, a song I love. I got the sense that he was performing more for himself than for the audience. This came as no surprise, as I felt that way I when I saw him perform last time. So that did not explain what was amiss.
I kept replaying the show in my head. As I did, I realized that when Tim and Faith sing a duet, Faith’s voice, which is so strong, just overpowers Tim’s. As a result, the show comes off as more of a Faith Hill show than a Tim McGraw show, despite the fact that Tim McGraw was, and still is, a bigger star with a bigger fan base. This seems to account for lots of the lukewarm comments. My suspicion is that if it was either a Tim or a Faith show, the comments would have been spectacular. Instead, it sort of fell flat, proving just how astute John Lygate was.
Pam and I had tickets to see Chris Stapleton at the Forum. Unfortunately, Pam was under the weather the day of the show, so I went with Kim, my younger daughter. I am lucky that Kim, at 29, still wants to spend time with me, and we have several interests in common, including cars and exercise. Many times we see the world the same way, and Pam likes to quip, “There they go, four arms and one brain!”
for the first opening act, Lucie Silvas, to begin. While we waited, I wondered why Lucie Silva was the opening act. Lucas, one of my co-workers who was also going to the show, had played a snippet of one of her songs the other day, and I could not get a handle on the genre. Nor could I fathom how her music fit within the musical space inhabited by Chris Stapleton and by The Brothers Osborne, the second opening act. Days after the show ended, I found out the relationship, but by then I didn’t care. Lucie Silva is an excellent musician. She has a great voice, and she put on a great performance.
While I bemoan the former, I cherish the latter. As far as my musical tastes go, Chris Stapleton and The Brothers Osborne are right down the middle of the fairway. I was excited to see both of them perform.
changes. No strutting. No playing to the audience. Not even too many guitar changes. Just a steady stream of absolutely perfect music. Eric Clapton, arguably the greatest guitar player and musician I have ever seen live, is not an entertainer, either. He is not dramatic. He is not flamboyant. What he is is good. Damn good. Chris Stapleton comes as close to Eric Clapton in terms of pure musicianship as I have ever seen. He was just that damn good.